Saturday, October 10, 2009

New NCTM HS Math Doc Does A Disservice

Guest post by Ze'ev Wurman

Review of "Focus in High School Mathematics," National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2009

This document stands out more for what it omits rather than for what it includes. It is full of paeans to reasoning and sense-making that it--quite properly--hails as the hallmark of mathematics. Yet reasoning and sense-making are not exclusive to mathematics. They are the cornerstones of history, of physical sciences, of economics, and even of political science. The reason mathematics is unique, that it has been called the Queen and Servant of Science, is not because it is focused on reasoning and sense-making, but because it is focused on formal reasoning--on mathematical proofs.

Yet reading the new NCTM document one might well not notice the concept of proof. The word "proof" appears a scant 27 times in the body of this 145 page document, one third of them in the short opening chapter which ties reasoning and sense making to proof. Yet even there, the first appearance of "proof" is immediately followed by "however", as in "However, mathematical reasoning can take many forms, ranging from informal explanation ..." (p.4) Another half of the occurrences of "proof" is found in the single geometrical semi-proof example in the text, with the other five incidences sprinkled elsewhere. Contrast that with almost 500 occurrences of "reasoning" and over 200 occurrences of "sense making" in this document.

In fact, much of the document is spent trying to confound reasoning and sense-making (which are present in every discipline) with formal proofs that are unique to mathematics. This is presumably made in an effort to make mathematics more accessible, yet it amounts to pouring out the baby with the bathwater. Without exception, all of the discussion is centered around so-called "real world" examples, and abstraction is essentially unmentioned. Reasoning and sense making are indeed important, in mathematics as in history, yet they are not the defining characteristics of mathematics, as NCTM pretends they are. The formal aspects of mathematical proof, and its powerful abstractions, are what makes mathematics uniquely effective. Spending almost 150 pages with barely a mention of prerequisite mathematical knowledge and skills, and with nary a paragraph promoting proof or abstraction as the keys to mathematics, and to its enormous utility in all domains of life and science, is NCTM's disservice to all of us.

At this point it is almost pointless to mention the other deficiencies of this document: The exclusive focus on reasoning and sense-making comes with the deprecation of almost anything else in mathematics, and particularly skills and procedural fluency. Readers are warned that students may "capriciously invoke incorrect or baseless rules" without understanding (p.12) yet nowhere is a similar warning of careless or unsubstantiated reasoning given. Little time is spent on mentioning content, with the exception of promoting--without any research support--yet more probability, statistics, and discrete mathematics in the curriculum, topics that NCTM has been promoting for decades as its antidote to the "traditional math." Some things never change.

58 comments:

  1. Thanks for this review. It confirms my take on the NCTM document.

    What is wrong with high schools focusing on mathematical concepts, content, and skills?

    page 4 reasoning -- the process of drawing conclusions on the basis of evidence or stated assumptions.

    What is it called when math education experts and decision makers draw conclusions in the absence of evidence, or the presence of fraudulent evidence, or false assumptions?

    It is scary to think of the decisions that will be made based on the existence of this document. The majority of those decisions will not make any reasonable sense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am a college math professor. The NCTM types focus on reasoning, etc., but when these kids get to college they can't compute anything and even those who make it to Calculus are extremely weak. Besides emphazing proof (which any such document should) it should make it clear that students need to be strong at compuation. Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills and have absolutely no idea what a mathematical proof is. The Harvard Calculus text was the completion of the demolition of mathematics - make math open to all by taking out all theory and computations. What is left is math-lite, if that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As a parent, your views are quite enlightening. I have to admit I am more worried about my kid's math skills.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow! That's very interesting. The benefits are obviously many.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nowadays hundreds of online services offer students to buy essay, to prepare any kind of homework or take online tests.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include almost all vital info. I would like to see more posts like this.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for posting this useful info. It really helped me

    ReplyDelete
  8. hundreds of online services offer students to buy essay, to prepare any kind of homework or take online tests

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills and have absolutely no idea what a mathematical proof is

    ReplyDelete
  10. this is very interesting, I will consider
    and thank you for sharing...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Acabo de marcado tu blog y quería decir que he disfrutado mucho leyendo su blog. Estoy de acuerdo con la mayoría de las preguntas que usted ha dicho y estoy esperando a mas posts

    ReplyDelete
  12. like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills and have absolutely no idea what a mathematical proof is.

    ReplyDelete
  13. They are the cornerstones of history, of physical sciences, of economics, and even of political science. The reason mathematics is unique

    ReplyDelete
  14. g proof (which any such document should) it should make it clear that students need to be strong at compuation. Thanks to the NCTM -like math de-education, we have had over 20 years of students who are lacking basic arithmetic, algebraic/trigometric skills

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for such a nice post, Thanks to the NCTM in builting our concepts by providing so many examples, your article must work thanks for your great contribution.

    ReplyDelete
  16. NCTM works great, they provide so many examples on mathematics, and i also agreed your saying that no body learn mathematics in one day and math contains so many concepts,which we either didnt here.Thanks for posting such great article.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow,NCTM take a nice step towards focus in high school mathematics,it's a responsibility of our government to pay attention also on these institution and provide new and fast technology because by these institution mathematics move towards more success.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for the great info. I’ll be implementing much of this soon!

    ReplyDelete
  20. thanks a lot for the post! very interesting!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Very nice written but very hard to understand because written with very hard vocabulary,although i like it becuase there are some thing which i understood and i use those things in my life that's why i like all it.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The article on focuses in high school mathematics written very well its nice news for me that this thing going to happen now.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi, this is first time i am visiting your site and happy to see such a great article here, so many things new i came to know by your article. Thanks for all your efforts you made here for us. Will back soon for more updates.

    ReplyDelete
  24. He is playing multiple parts in two different productions – Henry V and The Winter’s Tale – and even taking on the role of a woman who speaks some French, so it is going to be no walk in the park.

    atlanta roofing specialists

    ReplyDelete
  25. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hi, this is first time i am visiting this site and so happy to see such a great info here, the way you guys described everything here is amazing. Thanks for all of your efforts you made here, will back soon for more updates.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Excellent and decent post. I found this much informative, as to what I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Wow, this is pretty interesting. Inspiring, as well. Thanks for sharing such inspiring experience with us. Great blog, congrats.!

    ReplyDelete
  29. WOW! what a great concept art. I love how you got the guy that was originally Sonic to return!!!!!!!! you guys are doin great! keep up the good work .

    ReplyDelete
  30. Oh! Amazing work with the article. I find few helps over here related by this post to do my task nicely. I highly recommend this. Thanks a lot……… Custom essay.

    ReplyDelete
  31. ut his trust in a supplier of five years, who then framed Rubesch for his own crime. Even after the charges were dropped, with the case never making it to trial and the story pulled from the papers, Rubesch l
    http://rjandcogroup.com.au/

    ReplyDelete
  32. In 1952, Ray-Ban created another classic style, the Ray Ban Wayfarer 2140, this time with plastic frames. They soon became popular in Hollywood, and can be seen on James Dean in 1955’s Rebel Without a Cause.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Bienvenue à acheter les meilleurs tods en ligne. Vous pouvez obtenir la qualité officielle et le prix pas cher à notre magasin. Livraison gratuite!!!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Programa espacial Asics Mini Cooper junto con la técnica de inducción afectar TRUSSTIC, para aumentar sus movimientos normales actuales y también la respuesta de la Tierra.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I went over this internet site and I believe you have a lot of fantastic information, bookmarked Your Site.

    ReplyDelete
  36. The article make every detail of the story depicts streaming with the best, and every movement of the characters all write so lifelike.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Very useful post. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. Really its great article. Keep it up

    ReplyDelete
  38. Thanks for useful information! Besides, if you don't have enough time to write your papers, don't hesitate to use online custom essay writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Cheap Ray-Ban Eye Sunglasses Factory Outlet Online Store,Ray bans is the most popular and best selling sunglasses brand in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Since 1854, Louis Vuitton has been passed down to the excellent quality, outstanding creativity and craftsmanship to become a symbol of fashion travel art.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Burberry is a very traditional British style luxury brand, its multi-level products to meet consumer demand for different age and gender.

    ReplyDelete
  42. whoah this weblog is terrific i really like reading your posts. carry on the terrific function! You already recognize, many persons ar seeking spherical for this data, youll be able to aid them greatly.

    ReplyDelete
  43. This is very useful and effective blog. I was finding this type of information from long time about marketing basics.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Everything is beautifully define in your blog. Thanks for your useful info.

    ReplyDelete
  45. A current client of mine is relocating to your erea and wanted me to find a practice to suit their families needs.

    ReplyDelete
  46. I wanted to know if anyone has used it and how well it works. Thanks in advance..

    ReplyDelete
  47. It was extremely beneficial for me. Retain sharing such tips in the future also. This was actually what I was trying to find, and I'm glad to come here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Well, this post is well-written. Thanks a lot.
    Do not lose an opportunity to bu essay at an affordable price.

    ReplyDelete
  49. this is very interesting, I will consider and thank you for sharing.
    Most of my own qustions continues to be awnsered.thanks. on all other issues I will find the answer on our site http://custom-paper-writing.org

    ReplyDelete
  50. College essay Topics is one of those essay writing companies, which do their very best to make the customers 100% satisfied with their services.

    ReplyDelete